Tuesday, March 24, 2015



Language Post


     While engaging in conversation with my daughter is always a joy, this experiment took it to a whole new level.  Conversing without words was quite the task.  My attempts to solicit or respond to a question usually ended with my palm to my forehead.  At times, I would catch myself trying to play charades.  On the other hand, my daughter was able to carry on conversation whether I responded correctly or not.  She always seemed to be three subjects ahead, whereas I was still trying to get her to understand my first message.  If I was trying to talk about our dog, she was talking about the kitchen.  For the most part this assignment was frustrating, I could not imagine not being able to talk.  In this case my daughter took full control of the conversation.  The fact that she was in complete control, gave her the ability to change topics, ask and answer the questions, as well as exclude me from the conversation.  As a matter of fact, if there were not a fifteen-minute time limit, she would probably still be talking.  The balance of power was definitely tilted her way and she enjoyed every minute.  Once again with her in control of the conversation, it didn’t matter what I was trying to say.  She would simply move on to the next subject.
     If we were two different cultures where one uses spoken language and the other does not, the culture with the spoken language would have the advantage in communicating complex ideas within their population.  The culture with the spoken language would be able to share information verbally, visually, and with a hands-on approach.  The culture that does not use spoken language may only communicate visually and with a hands-on approach.  The lack of verbal communication inhibits this culture.  The speaking culture in this case may look down upon the culture that does not use symbolic language as if they lack intelligence.  A modern situation that might resemble this relationship between a culture that can speak and culture that cannot would be parents and their newborn baby.  A baby is unable to express itself verbally therefore making it difficult for the parents to understand the needs of the infant.
     Speaking without any physical embellishments was no easy chore.  Especially attempting this with my daughter.  I felt like the teacher from Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, lacking complete emotion. However, this time around she didn’t have the upper hand.  I was able to say exactly what I wanted to say, I could change the subject, and I actually felt like I was included in the conversation. The only problem was that it was one boring conversation!  So boring, that during our discussion she started playing her ukulele.  The lack of body language and vocal intonation was nearly impossible.  I found that to be very difficult and as previously stated my daughter found me to be very boring.  She seemed uninterested to the entire conversation.  My daughter had no problem comprehending; it was the absence of emotion on my part that kept her from engaging in conversation. 
     Non-speech language is an important role of effective communication.  This type of communication plays a vital role alongside verbal communication.  It allows the audience to capture feelings from the speaker.  Our emotions are displayed in our body language.  If a person were to read our body language they might see some of the following: a smile that represents happiness, a shoulder shrug may signify unawareness, eye rolling could imply disbelief or disgust, and hands on your hips might suggest dominance.   
     The adaptive benefit to possessing the ability to read body language is vital in our lives.  We have become dependent on this ability.  When we communicate with each other we tend to seek each other’s emotions.  For example, we might try to motivate somebody when they seem discouraged or know to console someone when they are sad.  The ability to read body language can help a person survive, obtain resources, and reproduce successfully by being able to understand the message that is being conveyed.      Realizing that somebody is a threat just by looking at their body language will automatically put you on guard.  You might fight, run, or even hide.  The look of a hungry, homeless child will provide them food, clothing and shelter. Additionally, males and females flirt with each other in hopes of finding a mate and eventually producing offspring.

     The blind are an obvious group of people that have difficulty reading body language.  Some children with learning disabilities may also have trouble-understanding non-verbal language.  A situation where there might be a benefit to not reading someone’s body language could be seen in people who are intoxicated or under the influence of drugs. The alcohol and drugs alter the normal state of mind, thus producing unreliable body language. 

4 comments:

  1. Great discussion on Part A!

    "As a matter of fact, if there were not a fifteen-minute time limit, she would probably still be talking. "

    Since I have a daughter myself, this comment had me chuckling!

    Good discussion on the issues of culture and yes, parent/child relationships are good examples of this. It is worth noting that we tend to treat those who don't speak our language very much like children, such as those who are non-native speakers and those with physical disabilities.

    Good description of part B. Participants usually interpret partner responses as "bored" but it is also a situation where they feel uncomfortable and it is worth asking why they would be uncomfortable without body language.

    Yes, non-spoken language contributes meaning and clarification, but it also allows people to verify what you are saying, kind of like a lie-detector. If your body language doesn't match the words you are saying, this tells the person that you aren't telling the truth and perhaps can't be trusted. Why would this be beneficial in an adaptive sense?

    Yes, those who are blind have difficulty reading body language, though they can hear vocal intonation. Those in the autism spectrum also have problems reading body language.

    Actually, those who are drugged or intoxicated are the least likely to have misleading body language. Body language is very hard to fake and if you are drunk, you won't have the mental faculties to manipulate your body language. Body language will be exaggerated but accurate. So when might body language lie, or when might you misread body language? Do all cultures use the same system of body language?

    ReplyDelete
  2. How cute is that. I agree with the professor she would most likely still be talking about the kitchen. I like your example of intoxicated people who misinterpret body language. They don't judge body language very well due to the overwhelming effect of intoxication . The blind is a very good example they are good at vocal alteration. They can tell moods by sound but they are at a disadvantage for facial body language they have to figure out what is being said through other modes of communication

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I feel as if I was in the same scenario as you were. I too felt like I was playing a game of charades, and it was a struggle to get any complex idea or function accomplished. On the other hand I did feel as if I was in control a little portion of part one of the experiment. True I had no way of communicating but sometimes it was me that was telling him something, and he that was trying to guess what it was, by asking me.

    ReplyDelete